Francesca Woodman: Remembering the Artist 40 Years On

40 years ago today—19 January 1981—a young woman, a talented American photographer, died. She was just 22 years old.

Self portrait.

Francesca Woodman was her name. In her short life, she had produced a collection of more than 800 photographs, each one individually unique, yet collectively they bear a distinctive, unifying aesthetic:

Self-deceit, Rome, Italy, 1978.
House #3 Providence, Rhode Island (1976).
Untitled, New York, 1979-80.

Dreamlike, whimsical, dark, just out of reach: Woodman’s photographs display a sense of self, as often she herself stood in as the subject, citing the “convenience” of having herself be the model. Her work is ethereal, as objects blur and move due to long exposure, while the lighting is soft and subtle. The daughter of artist parents, Francesca’s father gave his daughter her first camera, a 2.25-inch-by-2.25-inch Yashica, that she would use for most of her career. Taking her first self portrait at 13, it marked the beginning of a unique, and painful, journey.

Untitled, Rome, 1977-78.

I first came across Woodman’s work on Instagram last summer. I was immediately intrigued by the black and white images, undeniably creative in the poses, subjects, and expressions captured. They are such a stark contrast to the aesthetic offered on “Insta,” of near neon colored images with impossibly perfect subjects, with no flaws—or soul for that matter—to be found. Clearly, Woodman’s photographs were taken and developed before the digital age.

Rare color self portrait, circa 1979.

Accompanied with the images was this self portrait (above) of the very photographer, Francesca Woodman. Judging from the clothes, hair and type of camera pictured, I assumed Woodman was a photographer from the 1950s. Her aesthetic was yester-decade, not at all contemporary, but in a cool and natural way. When I came across this other self portrait, however, I had a sudden sense of foreboding.

Self portrait, circa 1977.

She looks so…melancholy. Without having to look right away, I felt that her career—and life—had been short. I was already surprised that the majority of her work was taken in the 1970s, not the 50s; her aesthetic was already “retro” during the disco age. But I noted that the dates of the images I saw, never went any further. It was if the photographs—and the artist—simply stopped. I did some more research, and my forebodings were confirmed: Francesca committed suicide that January day, 40 years ago.

From Angel series, Rome, Italy, 1977.

Knowing this, it’s all the more tempting to truly dive into her work, looking for clues that explain the why of what she did. For example, many of the photographs display the female form, nude, but not in a sexual or graphic way; many proponents claim Woodman’s art as feminist, as a “taking back” of the female form as when captured on film by a woman. However, Woodman herself never explicitly identified herself, or her work, as feminist. Many other images consist of the subject, usually Woodman, with her face and/ or body partially or completely obscured. Here, it’s easy to conclude that such images refer to a loss of identity.

Space 2, 1976.

Ask an art critic of what they make of Woodman’s images, and I’m sure you’ll get in-depth analyses. I’m still new to Woodman’s work, but regardless there’s a mastery in the creative genius the girl had. Its clear she had a passion for photography, yes, but more so for the aesthetic she captured on film. Her dedication to her craft was clearly there. So why did she end her life?

Untitled, 1980.

Like me, Francesca was born and raised in Colorado. She spent her formative years primarily in Boulder, where her parents worked as professors at CU. She spent summers in Florence, Italy, a place where her artistic aspirations thrived, as she was surrounded by museums. She took photography while at boarding school in Massachusetts, and in 1975 began attending Rhode Island School of Design (RISD), quite confident in her artistic abilities. As she further added to her portfolio, she remained determined to make her mark, specifically in becoming a fashion photographer. She thrived in school, but by the time she graduated, photography was not in vogue.

Moving to New York City, Francesca worked tirelessly in promoting her work and skills as a photographer, but met little success. Colleagues describe her as being needy and intense in nature, utterly dedicated to her craft but just as fragile in emotion. Acquaintances also cite Francesca’s desire to outshine the art accomplishments of her parents. Despite sending her portfolio to numerous companies and agencies, nothing came to fruition; others cited her work as too avant-garde. The first break came fall 1980, when Francesca attempted suicide for the first time. Family and friends did their best to monitor her, but her depression remained.

Eel Series, 1977-78.

When Francesca learned that her application for funding from the National Endowment of Arts was rejected, it appears that this was the final straw. Already dealing with the aftermath of a failed relationship, Francesca was in crisis. She made her final journal entry, then made her way to a nearby building in New York’s Lower East Side, and jumped from a window.

Untitled, 1979-80.

At her death, Francesca’s work was unknown. However, in the years and decades following, her work has, finally, garnered much attention and critical praise. Since 1985, there have been several solo exhibitions of her work, the latest having been 2019-2020’s Francesca Woodman: Portrait of a Reputation held at Denver’s Museum of Modern Contemporary Art (how I wish I’d attended)! There are also several books showcasing her photographs and notebooks, as well as a full length documentary, The Woodmans, released on the 30th anniversary of her death, in January 2011.

Book by Drew Sawyer and Nora Abrams, 2019.

I can’t help but wonder what Francesca, had she lived, would have made of social media, especially Instagram. Would she scoff at the “selfies” made by Milennials and Zoomers, citing them as uninspired, due to how easy it is to snap pics with a SmartPhone? How would she perceive SmartPhones as a device for taking photos? Are such devices blasphemous to photography? Or would she embrace all these changes, and perhaps envy Instagram, silently cursing for it not having existed when she was young, as it would’ve provided her with a more concrete platform for her work? Just as it so tempting, and easy, to analyze Francesca’s photography via the lens of her tragic death, so it is with asking these hypothetical questions. But one thing remains constant: Francesca’s conviction of her role as an artist, as she wrote, “I was (am?) not unique but special. This is why I was an artist…I was inventing a language for people to see the everyday things that I also see…and show them something different.” And that “something different” is what draws people to her photographs, as they “contrast to the cool slickness of the digital,” while embracing “tactility and decay in a very sensual and seductive way,” remarks Corey Keller, a curator of photography at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art. I couldn’t agree more. Francesca took photographs the old fashioned way, and combined with her artistic vision, made her images forever timeless—and forever haunting.

~LMC

*Note: All images are by Francesca Woodman unless where otherwise noted.

Five Years: Remembering David Bowie On the Anniversary of His Passing

On this day five years ago, much beloved singer-songwriter David Bowie passed away.

One of several promo pics for Blackstar, taken by Jimmy King.

One of things that people quickly learn about me—aside from me being an avid runner, outdoor enthusiast, horse and cat lover—is that I love David Bowie. My entire life I’ve been listening to his music. Several of my earliest memories are Bowie themed: toddler me watching David Bowie music videos on VHS; my Dad, himself a talented singer, playing “Space Oddity” on his acoustic guitar; my Dad and I eagerly awaiting and then listening to the latest Bowie albums released when I was a kid (Earthling, Hours…, Heathen, etc).

Bowie collage! This was a birthday gift for my Dad; I helped my Mom select and arrange the memorabilia. HUGE thank you to family friend Debbie for putting this together! 🙂

So, it was a shock, to say the least, when the news broke that Bowie had died; he’d never let slip that he’d been battling liver cancer for the past 18 months. Only his immediate family and a special few were aware. When it was announced on his official Facebook page that “David Bowie died peacefully today” the world was caught completely unawares. I remember that day quite clearly. I’d just arrived back home, after a drive of several hours. It was evening, I was tired, and I soon fell asleep on the couch. And I then had the most vivid vision: I was in a grayish-white room, and before me stood an upright hexagonal coffin. There was a small window over the face of the deceased. And the face was male, and I just knew I had a connection to this individual. I suddenly felt so frightened and disturbed that my breathing seized, and I awoke with a start. I was quite spooked, and perplexed: why did I see such an image?

Bowie as Button Eyes, in the “Blackstar” music video, 2015.

I was unable to sleep that night, so I stayed up scrolling through Facebook, when I saw that my friend (who is the ultimate country music lover) had posted, “RIP David Bowie.” What? I dismissed it as a hoax. Celebrities are constantly dodged by fake death announcements. But I had to check. I searched the web, and my doubt soon turned into shock. I literally stared at the wall, uncomprehending. Bowie was dead? But heroes don’t die. And your heroes especially, they never die. Right?

The official announcement.

The vision/ dream/ nightmare/ mere coincidence, call it what you may, slammed back into my consciousness. And it was then the tears started. I stayed up for another hour, feeling drained. Yes, I did not personally know the man. But what really hurt me was to think of Bowie’s daughter, Lexi, had just lost her father. She was just 15 then, much too young for any child to lose a parent. 🙁 Lexi, sending you a big hug.

Lexi and David; she posted this on her Instagram as a tribute on her father’s 74th birthday.

Bowie Beginnings

My Dad is the one who introduced me to David Bowie. He’s been listening to Bowie since the 70’s, when he first discovered Young Americans album while on a trip to England; he attended 10 Bowie concerts over the decades, and has dozens of Bowie vinyls and CDs. To be clear, he never forced me to listen to or like Bowie. He provided me the exposure, yes, but my fascination with Major Tom was natural, organic; I just grew up him hearing him and was completely fascinated by his many transformations, with music styles, characters, and appearance. His vocals, lyricism, his stage presence, are just mesmerizing. He was born to perform.

2004 Reality Tour poster in my room.

My Dad and I have always been close. So when I first thought of Lexi losing her father, it hurt me. I’m sure she was close to him. To her, he wasn’t David Bowie; he was her Dad. Bowie the man may be gone; but his legacy, his music lives on forever. Lives end, but legends live on forever. I hope that, in some small sense, this provides comfort to Lexi and Iman, Bowie’s wife.

I got this shirt when I was in middle school, now have it proudly displayed. 🙂

The day after his death, my Dad and I had a somber conversation on the phone, just reminiscing on our favorite albums and memories. My Grandma Brenda, my Dad’s mom, even emailed me to express her sympathy, writing that she herself enjoyed several of his songs. I then began re-listening to several albums of his, namely 1976’s Station to Station, and just, wow. His vocals are just so incredible, and playing the album was quite cathartic. It would be a little while, however, before I could give Blackstar a proper listen. When I finally did, it was quite the experience. Tony Visconti, who produced several Bowie albums, says it best: “He always did what he wanted to do. And he wanted to do it his way and he wanted to do it the best way. His death was no different from his life—a work of art. He made Blackstar for us, his parting gift. I knew for a year this was the way it would be.”

One of my all time favorite Bowie tracks. 🙂

Five Years On

I’m still incredulous that it’s already been five years since David has passed. Five years…any Bowie fan knows the significance of this number, as one of Bowie’s earliest songs is “Five Years.” Released in 1972, the song relays the story of Earth only having five years left, and individuals’ various reactions upon learning the news. After the initial shock of learning about his death, in other ways I was not at all surprised, when it came to how Bowie handled his failing health and imminent demise. Knowing Bowie and his mystique, it didn’t surprise me that he never divulged his cancer diagnosis to the public. For a man who had a 50+ year career in the spotlight, he was in so many ways very private. By keeping his diagnosis known to those only closest to him, he was able to enjoy the final 18 months of life with privacy, all while writing and recording Blackstar, his final album. Released on January 8, his birthday—and two days before his death—the whole record is clearly his swan song. “Look up here man / I’m in heaven,” are the opening lyrics to the single “Lazarus.”

Blackstar album cover art.

The stunning fact that Bowie’s diagnosis was never leaked until he finally succumbed, I think speaks volumes about the respect and awe people had, and continue to have, for him. For his whole career, he was constantly reinventing himself in terms of music styles, alter egos, and fashion, always ahead of the curve. It really warms my soul in knowing that Bowie’s career was so long that it spanned and influenced several generations. For example, my Dad clearly remembers purchasing Bowie vinyls as both a high school and college student in the late 70’s and early 80’s; Bowie was still releasing music when I was both in and out of college, in 2013 and 2016, respectively.

My folks and I attended “Celebrating David Bowie” at Denver’s Paramount Theatre, February 2018. Here my Dad and I pose with Bowie’s pic at Paramount Cafe.
Bowie parents! Mom and Dad all ready to watch A Bowie Celebration.

So, thank you Starman, for everything. Your massive creativity, talent, that certain mystique about you, live on. No one can ever replicate it. You are the soundtrack of my life. So many of my heroes have been long gone, some for centuries, but I and so many others count ourselves very lucky to have witnessed your career, your presence on Earth. In April 2004, I saw you perform live at Budweiser Events Center, in Loveland, CO, for your Reality Tour. It was a dream come true. I really can say I have seen David Bowie perform live. And it was utterly fantastic. And in many ways, bittersweet. It was both the first and last time I ever saw you. And it was also the last time for my Dad, marking the end to a decades long span of watching his hero on stage. We each wore a Bowie shirt, Dad letting me wear his shirt from Bowie’s ’78 tour; I felt so honored. I could easily keep going on, but I would like to end my ramble on this: we miss you Bowie, Major Tom, Aladdin Zane, Ziggy. And to my Dad (whom I, and others, have always thought could pass as Bowie’s brother): thank you.

~LMC

My Dad. 🙂

“Punk Pixie”—An Ode to Alice Glass, on her Birthday

Punk Pixie

I first saw your beautiful and forbidding face
in a music magazine.
Razor sharp cheekbones,
Death glare, heathen sounds, searing vocals:
A misfit friend found.

You were hardly 14,
when you ran away from home,
never revealing the reasons why
only providing your new name, a new soul:
Alice Glass.

Shards of innocence
stripped away
your companions the punks
of Downton Toronto.
Blue eyes dilated
skin sickly pale
hair once fair
dyed black to deny the image
that you were once a helpless child.

Your look: a mesmerizing witch,
Ripped tights
random shirts,
Jack Daniel's
in one hand,
a cigarette in the other.
A look formidable,
Always paired
With a pencil skirt.

You took to the stage
Staring down rabid males
A spirit more punk than theirs
Spitting beer in faces
Wielding the mic
Screaming your poetry.

I must admit that I’m surprised—
and utterly relieved—
That you’re still here.
That the angry cuts
The abusive creeps
The aching psyche
Did not silence you forever:
That which is the short, violent history of your life.

But at that show in Denver,
You proved yourself very much alive.
When you jumped into the crowd
There is absolution,
Born of adulation, inspiration, hope.
The image of your face becomes flesh,
As I hold you up to the heavens,
misfits and individuals bracing our friend,
the goth eccentric, rebel beauty
Alice Glass: a legend in my own time.

~LMC

This poem I wrote in college, dedicated to one of my true heroes, the lovely Alice Glass. A singer and songwriter, Alice holds such reverence in my heart in that she is utterly unique in both her life story and talent. Alice Glass is the former vocalist (and as far as I’m concerned the only vocalist) of my favorite band, Crystal Castles. An electro-punk duo, CC’s songs are seared into heart in the same way as Bowie is part of my identity. I love electronic music, and I discovered Crystal Castles at the right time: just before I started college. Their music was unlike anything I had heard before. From jarring, mind rattling 8-bit pieces (“Love and Caring,” “XXZXCUZ Me”) to dark synth ballads (“Suffocation,” “Wrath of God”), I was, and still am, enthralled. Mesmerized. A day does not go by that I do not listen to my beloved CC. I’m not kidding!

One of my favorite live Crystal Castles performances.

Just as my poem alludes to, I came across Alice in Spin Magazine, July 2010 edition. Accompanying a brief album review of the newly released Crystal Castles II, was a photo of one of the most beautiful women I have ever seen: Alice Glass. Her short black hair reminded of the Sneaker Pimps Kelli Ali, another badass female vocalist whom I revere. It was an immediate girl crush, that sense of having found a new friend for life. But it is not just Alice’s face that is stunning, but her aesthetic. This I immediately learned from watching CC music videos and live performances. Her dark eye makeup, punk yet feminine attire—black everything with a pencil skirt—paired with her fearless demeanor, is both striking, sexy, and confident. A no f&$#s given attitude. Diving into the crowd multiple times, climbing onto the drum kit, all while wailing out her soul: I had never seen such wild, naked passion in a singer, let alone a female vocalist. It was and is such a beautiful, reassuring thing to see. As a woman, I relate to and respect Alice in shattering expectations for women. Forget the plastic, robot façade pop singers of the mainstream: Alice was, is, and will forever be my girl crush, my role model, my hero.

Alice Glass at Fox Theatre, Boulder, CO, May 2018.

Alice departed CC in 2014, citing sexual, mental, and physical abuse by her own band mate, the other half of the duo. I won’t mention his name. Enough about him. Since then Alice has embarked on a solo career, with her first EP, the self titled Alice Glass, released August 2017 to critical acclaim. I love her new work. As one interviewer described the work, “Alice Glass sounds everything like and nothing like Alice Glass.” If you’re a CC fan hoping for more CC stuff, don’t bother. Alice continues to cultivate her own new sound, a catalyst for dealing with the trauma of her past, while still asserting her voice and her persona. A brilliant lyricist, she explores feelings of self doubt, hope, particularly rage and vengeance. One thing that has remained the same since Alice of the CC era: Alice’s passion and sincerity are ever present in her work, as I witnessed at her show at Boulder’s Fox Theatre, May 2018. She held my hand while cooing Celestica, and not once, but several times I sang literally right next to her when she stepped down onto the floor. The reverence she has for her fans is palpable, just as her fan base utterly adores her.

The album review that started it all.

10 years has passed since I discovered Crystal Castles on 26 June 2010; in this past decade I’ve followed and grown up with Alice and her journey. Just as my hero has experienced dizzying highs and terrible lows, Alice’s music has been there for me in my own journey. 

We love you Alice; never stop fighting.

~LMC

  • Featured photo of Alice Glass at top of page, and Moon Dagger, are from public domain.
L: Rockin’ the Alice Glass Moon Dagger! R: Crystal Castles II album cover.

Green Day’s 21st Century Breakdown Turns 10 Today

Ten years ago today, American band Green Day officially released their eighth studio album 21st Century Breakdown. My favorite Green Day album, I still enjoy listening to this particular work a decade later.

A lot of you already know I am a die hard David Bowie fan. I am also a Green Day fan as well. And while my love for them doesn’t quite match my love (read: obsession) for Bowie, if you knew my high school self, you would know I loved, and still love, this band.

I first got into Green Day when their highly acclaimed album, American Idiot, was released in September 2004. I was in 7th grade, the emo and iPod era, and remember just how HUGE that album was. Boys were imitating vocalist Billie Joe Armstrong’s look of all black wardrobe, messy hair, and guy liner. Girls wore Green Day band shirts, and you could overhear the album blasting on tinny earbuds. I remember purchasing a few songs on my iPod Nano, the songs “Boulevard of Broken Dreams,” and “Wake Me Up When September Ends,” being my favorites. In fact, the latter song served as my alarm on my iHome during my middle and high school days.

Once in high school, I started listening to other Green Day songs. My favorite pre tennis match pump up songs were “Welcome to Paradise” and “Brain Stew”. Keep in mind: these songs were already more than a decade old when I truly discovered them; Gen X grew up listening to these early songs and albums.

As much I liked American Idiot, I was ecstatic when Green Day released the single “Know Your Enemy,” in April 2009, to herald their latest album. 21st Century Breakdown is my album, from my era, a contemporary work. I remember watching the “Know Your Enemy” music video on YouTube, and counting down the days till May 15, the official release date. That day happened to be seniors’ last day at my high school. A junior, I distinctly remember standing above the commons, watching the seniors congregate in a mass of school papers flung everywhere, chanting, yelling. Gripping the balcony rail, anxiously tapping my foot, I muttered over and over, “One more year, one more year…”

The timing of the album’s release was poignant. Listening to it then, and even now, I knew that 21st Century Breakdown was, and is ,the soundtrack of my youth, of my teenaged self, my 17th year, my 17th summer. Society makes a big fuss about being 17. Oh to be 17 again…Yes. I get it. I loved being 17. I miss it. I remember purchasing the album shortly afterward, and listening to, memorizing, each track. Each song is so damn good, that I’m hard pressed to say that there’s any tracks where I hit the “Next” button.

And say what you will about Green Day selling out, gone commercial, gone POP instead of punk. I don’t care. You can’t deny that vocalist-guitarist Billie Joe Armstrong, bassist Mike Dirnt, and drummer Tre Cool are all such incredibly talented musicians. The songwriting, the lyrics, the hooks, the melodies: Green Day brings it all on this album. After the gigantic success of American Idiot, fans and critics wondered if Green Day could ever, or even desired, to top or match that success. Now, I’m no music critic, but 21st Century Breakdown is certainly no let down; in my opinion, the work matches the creativity and quality of its predecessor. Sectioned into three acts, the album’s theme, reflected through its title, centers on the bourgeoning hopes, fears, and anxiety that comes with the dawn of a new century. As with American Idiot, 21st Century Breakdown‘s narrative is portrayed through characters, these being the young punk couple Christian and Gloria. The album brings Green Day’s signature sound of raucous guitar and sledgehammer drums on tracks such as “Know Your Enemy” and “Horseshoes and Hand Grenades,” with Dirnt’s bass heavy on “East Jesus Nowhere,” and “Last of the American Girls.” The album’s other single, “21 Guns,” is a power ballad with an anti war message. A hard hitting song in both its lyrics and melody, this track once again confirms Green Day’s stellar songwriting abilities. For me however, my personal favorite song on this album is “Viva La Gloria? (Little Girl).” Opening with haunting piano notes, the track then builds into a crescendo of rockabilly sounding guitar and powerful bass lines, with the lyrics describing a woman whose destructive drug habit is forcing her onto the streets.

Guitar World Magazine article, August 2009

In this era of auto tune and zilch instruments for many of today’s top selling recording artists, Green Day remains so refreshing, so cathartic, to listen to: an actual band! And a rock band at that. Though many folks scoff at Green Day having long lost any sense of their original punk roots, once again, I do not care. The sheer talent within the melodies and songwriting is gold. This album is a true rock epic masterpiece, just like American Idiot.

For me, 21st Century Breakdown was forever sealed into memory upon listening to it during a Fourth of July weekend trip with my Dad. We were driving along the boundless tracks of eastern Wyoming, blasting it at top volume. My Dad, the one who introduced me to Bowie and many other classic rock artists, knows what good music is. And he loved that album. Still does. My Mom too; she’ll request that I play it for her. How cool is my Mom? 🙂 And to this day, whenever I think of Wyoming, 21th Century Breakdown starts playing in my head. Just last August I drove up to Laramie, and once I crossed the border into the Equality State, I immediately started playing the album: I was 17 again.

Denver Post review of Green Day’s performance at the Denver Pepsi Center, August 2009

Exactly three months after the album’s release, I saw Green Day live at the Denver Pepsi Center. I’d been playing a tennis tournament all day, was sunburned and tired. Didn’t care though. Show time, I dressed in my black skinnies, black Vans, and black shirt; I wanted to wear a red tie just like Billie Joe, but couldn’t find one in time.

And wow, Green Day did not disappoint. They played their new album, older songs, and several covers. It was a looong set: two hours or more. I remember watching the riot of the mosh pit from high above, reveling in a great time. I remember all the emo kids my age, and the Gen Xers who’d known Green Day from their early days. Just as the release of the album heralded summer break, that concert ushered in my final year of high school. The timing of that album could not have been more perfect. Green Day, thank you for the wonderful music and memories.

~LMC

Prescriptivism and Descriptivism in the Technology Age: Rules v. Reality (and Vice-Versa)

In today’s world, the so-called “Technology Age” and “Information Era,” there’s no doubting the large-scale impact rapid communication and technology continues to wield on reading, writing, and spoken language. Think about it: “LOL,” “JK,” and “TY” are not only seen as acceptable in many facets and fields of communication (written or spoken), but as mainstream. Just today I heard a young woman pepper her conversation and respond with “LOL” and “JK, JK,” while talking on the phone. “Text talk” has made the leap from not just being tapped out on screens, to being spoken in everyday life.

Cringing? Being a self-professed book worm and word nerd, “text talk” sometimes rubs me the wrong way, given the context (don’t you dare use numbers as stand-ins for words in academic papers)! But that doesn’t mean I haven’t typed out texts to my BFFs (best friends forever!) in a series of letters and digits (“cant wait 2 chill w/ u! its been 4evah!”) But I digress…

The abbreviations, omitted punctuation, and substituted spelling of “Text talk” is just one key example of how technology has changed how we learn and use language itself. And with the advent of social media: BOOM! Alphabet soup (or how about stew?) indeed. But considering how many gripe about this form of communication, is “text talk” really a sign that the English language is deteriorating, as many would have us believe?

Language: Rules v. Reality

“I didn’t do nothing!”

Say this aloud and you’ll draw the attention of the “Grammar Nazis” (i.e., your parents, teachers, or even a coworker). After all, this sentence is incorrect. You can’t say a double negative in English. The two negatives cancel out one another, so the sentence really means, “I did do something!” Double negatives just don’t align with the rules of English grammar.

This is prescriptivism, the concept of how language and communication should be. In other words, there are rules to follow. Function and form are key. Break these rules, and your own form of speaking and writing is “wrong.”

     Descriptivism, however, aligns itself with how language is utilized in real, everyday life. Slang and acronyms are great examples. For instance, are you fond of saying “ain’t”? Nothing wrong with this word, as that is what you use when speaking. Descriptivists aim not so much at correcting an individual’s speech or writing, but instead observe how language is actually used. So, while the phrase “I ain’t never seen nothing,” is grammatically incorrect, viewed with the prescriptivist lens, it is a valid statement.

 Language: It’s Alive!

            Before you go all Hunger Games and feel that you’re pitted against an adversary of your language views, you must know this: language is not a fixed thing. In fact, it is a living thing. Don’t believe me? Take a look at any Shakespearean play (not the modern-day transcripts on SparkNotes). Confused and frustrated already by what you’re reading? You see, language is ever changing. What Shakespeare wrote and spoke was “normal” in his day, but to communicate in that way today? You’ll garner laughs and weird stares alike.

All languages are forever dropping and gaining new words, new phrases, and even new grammar rules. Believe it or not, once upon a time in English, double negative usage was not only acceptable, but grammatically correct. That is until Robert Lowth penned A Short Introduction to English Grammar in 1762 and decreed that, along with other grammatical rules and restrictions, such usage is incorrect.  Hmm…can’t help but wonder what Mr. Lowth would have to say about “text talk.” So, given that languages are chameleons…can one still make the claim that a language is deteriorating? Improving? Which leads to us to speculate: what is the relationship of prescriptivism and descriptivism with today’s educators? And how does technology play into this?

Language Snob or Language Slob?

The role of an educator is, obviously, to properly educate and mentor students in whatever it is they are learning. If a teacher is teaching the wrong spelling or improper grammar rules, then they are failing their duty. This is especially true when first teaching children the fundamentals of how to read and write, which in turn affects their manner of communicating: educators must establish and encourage their students as to what is sound and correct, in “doing it right.”

HOWEVER:

 Education is more than just teaching the “rules;” learning is also being exposed to the realities of how knowledge is actually used and applied in the real world. I am not advocating that “text talk” be taught in schools (chances are your kid beats me at txt tlk, lolz!), but rather that both teachers and students keep an open mind as to how language is utilized in daily life. The “correct” and “right” way(s) of communicating does not equal that there is only one correct way to communicate. Just as thousands of different languages exist, different variants within a language exist (dialects), just as individuals possesses his or her own unique way of communicating (idiolect). Then factor in how the aspects of gender, culture, age, class, etc., are reflected in spoken language and written communication, and vice versa. The long-held idea of “Standard American English” suddenly appears a bit shaky. How does my “Standard” of English sound to others’ “Standards?” Who is the Snob and who is the Slob?

So, this means..?

For educators especially, technology can be viewed as both a boon and a curse when it comes to instructing and communicating, whether with other academics or with their own students. I remember college professors (yes, you read college) scolding students to refrain from using texting abbreviations in their papers (yikes)! Spell Check can both help and hinder, for while correcting spelling and checking grammar, it is not a foolproof function. A human is always a better proofreader than any computer or machine, and heavy reliance on Spell Check sometimes leads students to neglect or miss mistakes the function has failed to mark. And with instant information, plagiarism is all too easy, as anyone can cut-copy-paste anything and claim it as theirs.

On the flip side, however, technology can certainly enhance and strengthen the learning process. Just as a person can rip off another’s work, sites such as turnitin.com, for example, check written pieces for any evidence of plagiarism. With the Information Age being as widespread as it is, there are various computer programs/ online courses tailored to specific subjects, for different students. Peers can interact and collaborate on group projects, discuss a topic for class, and just offer help for one another.

With the pluses and cons that result from where technology, communication, teaching and comprehension intersect, it is key to keep context in mind. Scholarly works call for higher register and grammatically correct writing, just as a public speech demands precise and skillfully crafted language. Occasion also affects whether you take on more of a persona of the Snob or Slob. You wouldn’t dare curse in front of others at church, and you wouldn’t talk smack to your kind grandmother. But one needn’t be a snob around friends, as you joke with one another in a manner that is casual and lower register. One doesn’t have to be staunchly Prescriptivist or Descriptivist; both are needed. The key is finding balance. Educators may take the prescriptivism approach, especially with adolescent pupils, in establishing the groundwork in how to read, write, and communicate. But fostering creativity is also the educator’s job, and descriptivism permits this. Therefore, educators must understand when to encourage and enforce the rules, and when to both engage in and acknowledge the realities of actual language use.

In the end, we do need rules. If we did away with rules completely, and every one of us took up our own manner of speaking, it’d be the Tower of Babel all over again, communication rendered inefficient. Hardly anything would be accomplished. But a break from the rules is also needed, as variance in how language is used allows our individuality and creativity to show. Think about it: if everyone spoke and wrote the same, the world would sure be a boring place.

~LMC

*This piece originally written for and posted on Action Publishing: Educator Resources Blog, July 2016. https://www.actionagendas.com/blog/date/2016-07

JUSTIFY!!!

Today is a glorious day, for we have a new TRIPLE CROWN WINNER!

It’s not everyday, or even every decade, you get a Triple Crown winner, ie., a thoroughbred race horse to consecutively win the three crown jewels in American thoroughbred racing: the Kentucky Derby, the Preakness Stakes, and the Belmont Stakes. Including today’s winner, there have only been 13 Triple Crown winners. The last of the 70’s superstars won in 1978, and then ensued a nearly 40 years long drought.

I love horses, so it comes as no surprise that today’s win is viewed with great reverence. Until the 2015 triumph of American Pharoah (yep, his name is a misspelling), the first Triple Crown winner in 37 years, I’d begun to wonder if there’d be any TC winners in my lifetime…and if so, when? In 2015, I vividly remember watching the deciding race, the Belmont Stakes, while exercising on the elliptical. As American Pharoah flew down the homestretch, I knew there was no doubt, and when he crossed under the wire, I started hollering like none other. Funnily enough, that day the cardio room was empty save for me, though I’m certain a few people nearby heard my celebratory whoops.

Today I didn’t have the luck to witness the Belmont Stakes live, for I was at work. When I came home I watched the recorded race, and my Dad and I marveled at just how fluid Justify’s movement is. In the parlance of tennis obsessed freaks, father and daughter agreed that the brilliant chestnut stallion is “Federesque:” his effortless athleticism akin to the graceful movement of tennis playing great, Roger Federer. Both the horse and human athletes display efficient movement and prowess. Comparing Justify’s stride against the other horses, he flew while his opponents pummeled and strained over the track.

Any Triple Crown win is special, but this one more so as Justify’s jockey, Mike Smith, is the oldest jockey to ever claim a Triple Crown, at 52. From the brief pre and post race interviews alone it is easy to see just how much Mike loves his sport; he exudes enthusiasm and true passion. And as for Justify: he reminds of me of my beloved horse Flash, both in appearance and demeanor. Though he is taller than Flash, his calm behavior on and off the course are so much like my boy. The blaze and the eyes are also very reminiscent of my beloved horse…

And so, a very hearty congratulations to both horse and jockey! Justify, I would give you an apple if I could. 🙂

~LMC

 

DREAMS: EXPLORING A VICTORIAN RESIDENCE

Those who know me well are aware that I LOVE old buildings, particularly those from the Victorian era. I just love the aesthetic of these buildings: the tall, narrow windows, lattice work, brick work, wrap around porches, etc. These buildings, particularly residences, evoke both romance and nostalgia. Any chance I can visit a Victorian house, I take it…as I did in my dreams a few nights ago.

I was running east down a narrow dirt road overshadowed by the lushest cottonwoods. It was the height of summer, gleaming green, cloudless sky. I was in a valley in the foothills, the valley floor a series of gradual rises and abrupt gullies. I passed by a modern house or two without a second glance, concentrating more on staying in the shade as much as I could. I could smell blossoms in the air. As I descended a gentle slope, I immediately took notice of the stately house just to the left of me: a two story brick home, the long, narrow windows and wraparound porch denoting it as Victorian. Right above the main entryway, a stone engraving proclaiming “1885” more than confirmed my suspicions. I was so in awe I came to a sudden halt, and just stared at the impressive building. The bricks themselves looked worn with time, but one could easily tell that the home had since been painstakingly restored to its original grandeur: someone actually lived there. A white picket fence surrounded the gardens circling the house, and I noted the cottonwoods on the property were by far the oldest I’d seen on my run so far. If I could just go inside, was my thought.

It was then that I noticed an elderly woman with salt and pepper hair looking at me through a modern screen door in the main doorway. I averted my gaze, feeling awkward and started to walk away when she opened the door.

“Hey there! C’mon in if you like. It’s mighty hot out there, and I’d be more than happy to give you a tour of my home,” she waved at me from the porch.

I looked down at myself: I was a sweaty mess, my shirt practically soaked, my hair plastered against my skull. As gross as I felt, I wasn’t going to pass up on her offer.

It’s weird how dreams cut from scene to scene, like a movie. Next thing I recall is I’m inside the house, and just speechless at how beautiful the interior is. I know the woman and I introduced ourselves, as we kept referring each other by name, but sadly I can’t remember what I called her by. I followed right behind her as she showed me the first floor, and immediately I was struck by how original everything was: the wood floors, wall paper, furnishings, etc. Only a few items and modern conveniences were evident. For example, the kitchen had a state of the art fridge and microwave, yet there was an old stovetop in the corner. The parlor was a beautiful room with wine red wallpaper and velvet drapes at the corners, with one reading lamp in the corner. The furniture was beautiful walnut and from the 1880s, the majority of the furnishings original as they had belonged to the first owner, a woman homesteader from the 1880s. The new owner showed me a collection of sepia photographs showing the first owner and her family in Victorian Sunday best: the husband in a fine dark suit with pocket watch, the wife in a high collared blouse, her extreme hourglass figure created by a corset. My gracious host explained that this family had run a cattle ranch here for many decades, but eventually the ranch was sold and some of the land developed (evidenced by the modern houses I’d passed by). The family moved on, and their beautiful home fell into an abandoned state.

As we toured the second floor—beautiful furniture in the three bedrooms, a stately office complete with oak desk and inkwell—she explained she’d come to own the house and most of its possessions. But as dreams go, I don’t remember the exact details of how/ when she came to own such an impressive, historic place. What I do vividly remember is how envious I was she lived in this house on such stunning property!

The next “scene” we’re back in the kitchen, and I’m babbling my gratitude for her letting me in her home, and commending her for keeping the house as close as possible to its original state. Gracious as ever, the woman presented me a loaf of homemade banana bread with almonds!

****

The featured photo at the top of the page shows what best resembles what I saw in my dream. This particular Victorian home is the Mount Buninyong homestead in Australia, built in 1884, by the Scott family, who lived here raising cattle, and eventually sheep. Descendants of the Scott family still inhabit the property to this day. I know I have certainly seen buildings akin to this style here in the American West, but when I came across this photo via Pinterest, it looked so much what I saw in my dream, I honestly felt my body go cold. It felt like deja vu…And yet, the thing is, I’d never heard of this particular place before….

It is amazing just how much I immediately recalled everything upon waking from this dream. It’s so strange how certain dreams stay with you, while other mornings you know you dreamed of something but can’t remember a single detail. It is especially easy, and tempting, to want to pull meaning from dreams, to perform psychological analysis essentially…but all I will say that is that I loved this dream. It felt so real. It was a culmination of things I love: running, summer, old (Victorian) houses, history, banana bread. If I can “subscribe” to more dreams like this, sign me up!

~LMC

*Featured photo from http://vhd.heritagecouncil.vic.gov.au/places/67548

EQUINOXIN’

Happy Day of Equal Light and Dark, or…HAPPY SPRING! Whoot whoot!

Anyways, I confess that I have spring fever: restless and wanting warmer weather (i.e., I WANT SUMMER NOW)! Even Boots the Cat seems to be antsy, too. And yes, she DID attempt to distract me while I was setting up my computer to write, surprise surprise. In fact, I just realized I have CAT HAIR on the key pad, whelp.

~LMC

CURSE THE COMPUTER GODS

Oh sigh, apparently I have displeased the Computer Gods in that my laptop went completely kaput a few days ago. It was the dreaded Blue Screen of Death, the final death knell for my device. I have my phone of course, to keep me connected in this digitized world, but have been unable to write, or rather, type out posts. And so I undergo a quest to find a new computer! Wish me luck hehe 🙂

~LMC

 

CAT DISTRACTIONS

Great, the cat wants to eat my eyeball too..

All writers know—and despise!—writer’s block, the dreaded time when you just can’t…write. At all. Or well, at least. But do you have that one distraction that prevents or interrupts your writing? A clingy toddler? A messy room? (got to have your feng shui in order!)

For me, it’s my cat. A creature that is the very paragon of feline-ness: pointedly ignores all when you need companionship most, but then protests for attention at the most inconvenient of times. This is Bootsie. She is as far from a dog as you can get.

Initially I was writing a different post but Bootsie made known her need for attention: meowing pitifully at my door, breaking up my writing thoughts. I tried to ignore her. After all, she could’ve cuddled with me when I took a nap this afternoon. I even have her “nest,” or her favorite blanket, all set up at the end of the bed. But nope! Cats choose what they need, when they need it. This is what makes them so human, and why I love them so much (however much they irritate me at times).

Ceding to my cat’s wishes, I abandoned my initial post and opened the door. She shot in, hopped on her “nest,” and demanded that we CUDDLE RIGHT NOW, B%&$! She saw my lap top and decided for the moment that she wouldn’t crawl onto my lap. Normally, I don’t mind juggling cat and computer on my lap while surfing the web, but during writing time? NOPE! Whenever I was home from college right before finals week, she’d ALWAYS interrupt my studying: meowing at the door, hogging my desk chair, WALKING and SITTING across the keypad (she nearly deleted one of my essays)!

But tonight, I made known to her that I was going to resume writing, no matter how pissy she got. Unable to resume my other post, I started this one instead. I know it won’t be the last time Bootsie interrupts my writing time. Like my muse, the cat shows at the oddest times. So now it goes I type this sitting against the side of my bed, Bootsie just above my shoulder and purring like a motor boat. Annoying though she may be, I’d like to think she’s cheering, or rather purring, me on. It’s nice to know I have support in my writing endeavors.

And plus…ever since Flash entregar el alma (one of my fave Spanish colloquial phrases; best translation is “gave up the ghost”), Bootsie has been unusually loving and more purry. So thank you Boots. I mean it.

POST SCRIPT: Right when I finished this and got ready to post is when Bootsie decided to make her exit. Figures. Friggin’ felines 😉

~LMC